Skip to content
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
FREE Cold-Pack Shipping On Orders $69+ To All 50 States
Menu
Menu
Hamburger Menu
SALE
Subscription Boxes
Deal of the Month
Collections
All Products
Sale
Aged Cheeses
Artisan Meats
Best Sellers
Cheese Blocks
Cheese Curds
Charcuterie Boards & Accoutrements
Oven-Baked Cheese
Pairings
Package Deals
Father's Day
Gift Packages
Wholesale
Corporate Gifts Inquiry
Reviews & About Us
Reviews
Why Choose Gardner's?
About Us
FAQ & Contact
FAQ
Contact Us
Gardner's Blog & Recipes
Log in
Create account
Search
SALE
Subscription Boxes
Deal of the Month
Collections
All Products
Sale
Aged Cheeses
Artisan Meats
Best Sellers
Cheese Blocks
Cheese Curds
Charcuterie Boards & Accoutrements
Oven-Baked Cheese
Pairings & Sauces
Package Deals
Father's Day
Gift Packages
Wholesale
Corporate Gifts Inquiry
Reviews & About Us
Reviews
Why Choose Gardner's?
About Us
FAQ & Contact
FAQ
Contact Us
Gardner's Blog & Recipes
Log in
Create account
Manage Subscription
NOW TRENDING
Sour Cream & Onion Cheese Curds *LIMITED EDITION*
Cheese Curds (Squeaky Cheese)
Jalapeno String Cheese
8-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar
Draw-String-Cheese Whips
Bacon Oven-Baked Cheese
Chili Cheese Squeaky Curds
Buffalo Wing Cheese
Raspberry Honey Mustard
Search our site
Log in
Search our site
Search
Close (esc)
Cart
0
items
Cart
0
items
Log in
Quick Order
Cheese Curds (Squeaky Cheese)
$8.99
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Cheese Curds (Squeaky Cheese)
Unit price
/
per
Bacon Oven-Baked Cheese
$9.85
Sale price
$10.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Bacon Oven-Baked Cheese
Unit price
/
per
Italiano Oven-Baked Cheese
$9.85
Sale price
$10.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Italiano Oven-Baked Cheese
Unit price
/
per
Original Oven-Baked Cheese
$9.85
Sale price
$10.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Original Oven-Baked Cheese
Unit price
/
per
Garlic Oven-Baked Cheese
$9.85
Sale price
$10.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Garlic Oven-Baked Cheese
Unit price
/
per
8-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar
$11.95
Sale price
$13.50
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, 8-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar
Unit price
/
per
Oven-Baked Cheese Bundle
$83.45
Sale price
$94.55
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Oven-Baked Cheese Bundle
Unit price
/
per
Oven-Baked Cheese filled with 5-Year-Aged Cheddar
$11.49
Sale price
$12.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Oven-Baked Cheese filled with 5-Year-Aged Cheddar
Unit price
/
per
Garlic & Dill Flavored Cheese Curds
$9.45
Sale price
$10.45
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Garlic & Dill Flavored Cheese Curds
Unit price
/
per
Smokey Bacon Cheddar
$7.49
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Smokey Bacon Cheddar
Unit price
/
per
Aged Gouda
$7.95
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Aged Gouda
Unit price
/
per
Buffalo Wing Cheese
$8.06
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Buffalo Wing Cheese
Unit price
/
per
Maple Bacon Flavored Cheese Curds
$9.45
Sale price
$10.45
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Maple Bacon Flavored Cheese Curds
Unit price
/
per
Teriyaki Snack Sticks
$11.19
Sale price
$13.99
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Teriyaki Snack Sticks
Unit price
/
per
Draw-String-Cheese Whips
$7.49
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Draw-String-Cheese Whips
Unit price
/
per
Garlic Summer Sausage
$9.77
Sale price
$13.95
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Garlic Summer Sausage
Unit price
/
per
Chipotle Oven-Baked Cheese
$9.85
Sale price
$10.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Chipotle Oven-Baked Cheese
Unit price
/
per
Spicy Beef Snack Sticks
$11.19
Sale price
$13.99
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Spicy Beef Snack Sticks
Unit price
/
per
Horseradish Cheddar
$9.49
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Horseradish Cheddar
Unit price
/
per
Salty Smoked String Cheese
$9.45
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Salty Smoked String Cheese
Unit price
/
per
Holey-Smoked Swiss & Cheddar *NEW*
$8.75
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Holey-Smoked Swiss & Cheddar *NEW*
Unit price
/
per
Italian Herb Bruschetta Cheddar *NEW*
$7.46
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Italian Herb Bruschetta Cheddar *NEW*
Unit price
/
per
Smokin' Hot Pepper Jack
$6.49
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Smokin' Hot Pepper Jack
Unit price
/
per
Honey Ham Snack Sticks
$11.19
Sale price
$13.99
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Honey Ham Snack Sticks
Unit price
/
per
Jalapeno Oven-Baked Cheese
$9.85
Sale price
$10.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Jalapeno Oven-Baked Cheese
Unit price
/
per
Onion & Garlic Jack
$7.49
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Onion & Garlic Jack
Unit price
/
per
BBQ Snack Sticks
$11.19
Sale price
$13.99
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, BBQ Snack Sticks
Unit price
/
per
Oven-Baked Cheese filled with Aged Parmesan
$11.49
Sale price
$12.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Oven-Baked Cheese filled with Aged Parmesan
Unit price
/
per
Blue Marble Jack
$8.25
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Blue Marble Jack
Unit price
/
per
Aged Parmesan
$12.35
Sale price
$13.75
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Aged Parmesan
Unit price
/
per
Dill Pickle Meat Sticks
$11.19
Sale price
$13.99
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Dill Pickle Meat Sticks
Unit price
/
per
13-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar
$15.95
Sale price
$19.50
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, 13-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar
Unit price
/
per
17-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar
$32.00
Sale price
$40.00
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, 17-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar
Unit price
/
per
Buffalo Wing Oven-Baked Cheese *NEW*
$9.85
Sale price
$10.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Buffalo Wing Oven-Baked Cheese *NEW*
Unit price
/
per
Dry Aged Cheddar
$10.45
Sale price
$11.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Dry Aged Cheddar
Unit price
/
per
Chili Cheese Squeaky Curds
$9.45
Sale price
$10.45
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Chili Cheese Squeaky Curds
Unit price
/
per
The Oven-Baked Essentials Bundle
$67.95
Sale price
$75.65
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, The Oven-Baked Essentials Bundle
Unit price
/
per
Teriyaki Twin-Pack *NEW*
$3.35
Sale price
$3.95
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Teriyaki Twin-Pack *NEW*
Unit price
/
per
Mozzarella String Cheese *NEW*
$7.49
Sale price
$8.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Mozzarella String Cheese *NEW*
Unit price
/
per
Sour Cream & Onion Cheese Curds *LIMITED EDITION*
$9.45
Sale price
$10.45
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Sour Cream & Onion Cheese Curds *LIMITED EDITION*
Unit price
/
per
Hot Pepper Bacon Jam
$7.85
Sale price
$8.45
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Hot Pepper Bacon Jam
Unit price
/
per
Just Because Package
$69.49
Sale price
$87.19
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Just Because Package
Unit price
/
per
Raspberry Honey Mustard
$6.95
Sale price
$8.45
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Raspberry Honey Mustard
Unit price
/
per
Wisconsin Cheese and Sausage Sampler
$44.50
Sale price
$54.30
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Wisconsin Cheese and Sausage Sampler
Unit price
/
per
Hot Honey Drizzle
$10.77
Sale price
$13.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Hot Honey Drizzle
Unit price
/
per
Curated Cheese and Meat Subscription Box
$79.00
Sale price
$92.00
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Curated Cheese and Meat Subscription Box
Unit price
/
per
Wire Cheese Slicer *NEW*
$6.95
Sale price
$9.95
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Wire Cheese Slicer *NEW*
Unit price
/
per
Pizza Style Cheese Whips *LIMITED EDITION*
$9.45
Sale price
$9.95
Variant
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Quantity
1 Pack
4 Pack
8 Pack
Regular price
Sale price
Add to Cart
, Pizza Style Cheese Whips *LIMITED EDITION*
Unit price
/
per
1
2
3
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
FREE COLD-PACK SHIPPING ON ORDERS $69+ (ALL 50 STATES)
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.
Your cart
-
Close (esc)
Your cart is currently empty.
New subtotal: $0.00 USD
