Artisan Cheeses, Delivered Fresh to Your Door!

Are you ready to embark on a delectable journey? Do you dream of exquisite flavors melting on your tongue, of textures that delight, and aromas that transport you to a new world? Look no further! Welcome to the ultimate online destination for cheese connoisseurs and casual nibblers alike. We’re not just selling cheese; we're delivering an experience, a taste revelation, right to your doorstep! Forget lackluster supermarket selections, because it's time to indulge in the extraordinary. Welcome to Gardner’s Wisconsin Cheese: your home for handcrafted, small-batch cheese delivered fresh to your door.

Why Choose Gardner’s Curated Cheese Collection?

At Gardner’s, we believe buying cheese should feel like a discovery. Every wedge, curd, and oven-baked slab tells a story of Wisconsin farms, family craftsmanship, and generations of cheesemaking expertise.

Our passion for cheese runs deep, and it shows in every bite.

Unbeatable Freshness, Guaranteed!

“How fresh can online cheese really be?” you might ask. The answer: incredibly fresh.

Every Gardner’s order is packed and shipped directly from our Marshfield facility using cold-pack shipping with insulated packaging and ice packs that keep your cheese perfectly chilled. We ship Monday through Wednesday to maintain optimal freshness, ensuring your cheese curds arrive squeaky and your oven-baked cheese stays crisp and flavorful.

A World of Flavor, Just a Click Away!

Whether you crave the squeak of fresh cheese curds, the golden crisp of our Oven-Baked Cheese, or the bold complexity of Aged Cheddar, Gardner’s has a flavor for every palate.

Try Buffalo Wing Oven-Baked Cheese for a kick, or Maple Bacon Curds for something sweet and smoky. Explore family favorites or discover new indulgences, all made with Wisconsin’s finest dairy.

Crafted with Care and Wisconsin Integrity

Great cheese starts with great milk and honest methods. Gardner’s partners with local Wisconsin dairy farmers who share our values of quality, sustainability, and tradition. Our cheeses are made in small batches using time-honored techniques that preserve authentic flavor while supporting local agriculture.

When you buy from Gardner’s, you’re not just getting great cheese. You’re supporting Wisconsin’s proud dairy heritage.

Explore Gardner’s Irresistible Cheese Categories

Ready to dive into the wonderful world of cheese? We've organized our delectable offerings into easy-to-browse categories to help you find exactly what you're craving (or discover something entirely new!).

Squeaky Cheese Curds

Fresh, fun, and full of Wisconsin character. From Original to Garlic & Dill, our curds are made daily for the perfect squeak and flavor in every bite.

Oven-Baked Cheeses

The star of your next snack board. These unique slabs brown beautifully in the oven or air fryer while staying warm and chewy inside. Try Buffalo Wing, Bacon, or Garlic for crowd-pleasing favorites.

Aged Cheddars & Blocks

Our aged cheddars, including our 5-Year and 13-Year, offer deep, nutty richness and crumbly perfection. They are the cheeses that make Wisconsin famous.

Pairings & Gourmet Additions

Round out your board with Hot Pepper Bacon Jam, Raspberry Honey Mustard, or one of our artisan sausage selections made to complement every cheese you love.

Build Your Own Wisconsin Cheese Board

Every great gathering starts with cheese. Gardner’s makes it easy to design a showstopping spread: mix curds, oven-baked slabs, and aged blocks, then add sweet and savory pairings for balance.

Pairing Perfection:

• Cheese Curds with light beer or crisp cider

• Oven-Baked Cheese with marinara or ranch

• Aged Cheddar with wine, nuts, and fruit preserves

Add Garlic Summer Sausage for a savory contrast, and finish with a drizzle of honey or jam for texture and color.

How Our Fresh-Delivery Service Works

1. Choose Your Favorites

Browse our online shop, add your cheeses, and build your perfect box. Not sure where to begin? Try the Oven-Baked Essentials Bundle or the Wisconsin Cheese and Sausage Sampler.

2. We Pack It with Care

Every order ships in insulated cold-pack packaging to maintain ideal temperature during transit.

3. Delivered Fresh Nationwide

Whether you are in Chicago or California, your cheese will arrive cool, fresh, and ready to eat.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you keep the cheese fresh during shipping?

• We use insulated packaging, gel ice packs, and cold-pack shipping methods tested to maintain freshness nationwide.

Do you ship everywhere in the U.S.?

• Yes. We proudly deliver fresh Wisconsin cheese to all 50 states.

Can I send cheese as a gift?

• Absolutely. Add a note at checkout and we’ll make it gift-ready with a personal touch.

Do you offer package deals or samplers?

• Yes. Check out our Snack Pack, Oven-Baked Big Bundle, or Vintage Package to try multiple varieties at once.

Ready to Taste Wisconsin’s Best? Order Today!

Stop dreaming of cheese and start enjoying it. Whether you’re after the squeak of fresh curds, the crisp of oven-baked perfection, or the richness of aged cheddar, Gardner’s Wisconsin Cheese delivers the flavor of America’s Dairyland straight to your door.

Not sure where to start? The Top Sellers Gift Set Special is a perfect introduction to the best of Wisconsin.

Shop All Artisan Wisconsin Cheeses Here!