Orders $54+ Receive Free Cold-Pack Shipping | $59+ Free Curds | $89+ 2nd Free Curds | $129+ Free 17-Year Cheddar ($40 value)

0

Your Cart is Empty

17-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar

42 reviews

GLUTEN FREE | EXTREMELY KETO-FRIENDLY!

Aged for 17 years, this is as sharp as it can possibly get! As rare as it is old, and almost impossible to come by elsewhere, our 17-year-old cheddar is incredibly rich on the palette. Creamy, smooth, and impeccably sharp; this is the ultimate cheddar to spoil yourself with!  LACTOSE FREE!

• Weight: 5.5 oz
• Pairing Recommendations: Whiskey, Pilsner, Champagne, Cognac, Chardonnay


ALL NATURAL

GLUTEN-FREE

KETO-FRIENDLY

HIGH PROTEIN

LOCAL DAIRY

Why buy from Gardner's?


Customer Reviews
5.0 Based on 42 Reviews
5 ★
98% 
41
4 ★
0% 
0
3 ★
2% 
1
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
0% 
0
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
    BW
    09/28/2022
    Bruce W.
    United States

    Awesome aged cheddar!!!

    I've had 10 year aged sharp cheddar several times and it was delicious. This cheese one-ups that for sure and though I bought two several weeks ago, I have one and a half left and will certainly be ordering this again in a few months!

    M
    09/23/2022
    Modina
    United States United States

    Fussy 87 year old father

    My hard to please 87 yo father has been looking for aged cheddar like they used to “cut off the wheel”. Being a product of the depression and very frugal, he minds his money. He approved the purchase of this cheese; despite the fact that he thought it was pricey. When he tried it, I expected from previous experience, that he would say it wasn’t worth the money. Not only did he say it did taste like the old cheese he’d been craving……he wants me to keep ordering more! Thank you for giving my father a taste of his younger years……good food brings back good memories for him. PS: He’s got a great Limburger cheese story!!

    DF
    09/05/2022
    Donna F.
    United States United States

    Don't save for a special occasion

    I'd never heard of 17 year old cheese, and I couldn't imagine how good it could possibly taste to justify the price. But let me tell you, there is NOTHING I could say to prepare you for how good this cheese is! If you're not a cheese freak, this is not the cheese for you. If you love SHARP SHARP SHARP cheddar, you will love this 17 year old cheese. In my house, it will not be around long enough to last until the next special occasion.

    BS
    08/26/2022
    Bill S.
    United States United States

    Excellent cheese

    17 years of sitting around on a shelf and wow! What an exquisite cheese. No graininess and a very creamy sharp flavor at the rear of the pallet.

    CM
    08/26/2022
    Cat M.
    United States United States

    Most awesome sharp

    This cheese is so good, it melts in your mouth. I know it sounds odd but this cheese can make you sweat a bit from its sharpness. Take a slice of cheese and a dill pickle spear uuuummmm.