17-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar

119 Reviews

GLUTEN FREE | EXTREMELY KETO-FRIENDLY!

Aged for 17 years, this is as sharp as it can possibly get! As rare as it is old, and almost impossible to come by elsewhere, our 17-year-old cheddar is incredibly rich on the palette. Creamy, smooth, and impeccably sharp; this is the ultimate cheddar to spoil yourself with!  LACTOSE FREE!

• Weight: 6 oz
• Pairing Recommendations: Whiskey, Pilsner, Champagne, Cognac, Chardonnay


ALL NATURAL

GLUTEN-FREE

KETO-FRIENDLY

HIGH PROTEIN

LOCAL DAIRY

Why buy from Gardner's?

Customer Reviews
5.0 Based on 119 Reviews
5 ★
97% 
116
4 ★
2% 
2
3 ★
1% 
1
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
0% 
0
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
    RS
    02/19/2024
    Rick S.
    United States

    Best in 45 years

    Absolutely the best aged cheese I’ve had since I was with a girlfriend who attended the University of Gwelth(?) in the late seventies. We’d go to farmers markets in Ontario and get some of the best aged cheeses.

    JM
    02/18/2024
    Joseph M.
    United States United States

    Cheese

    Awesome we love it

    JA
    02/12/2024
    Jeffery A.
    United States United States

    5 out 5 stars!

    Best cheddar I’ve tasted! My brother agrees.

    SB
    02/12/2024
    Sandra B.
    United States United States

    17 year old cheese review

    The 17 year old cheese was good but we prefer the 13 year old. I also placed an order last week as a gift for my daughter. Her family loved the gift.

    KP
    02/11/2024
    Karen P.
    United States United States

    Great Cheese

    My husband loves a good cheddar cheese. He loves well aged ones that are sharp. When the place I normally get him special cheese for his birthday was out of his favorite cheese, I found this online store and this cheese. I was NOT disappointed. This is now one of my husband's favorites.