Orders $49+ Receive Free Cold-Pack Shipping | $59+ Free Curds | $89+ 2nd Free Curds | $129+ Free 17-Year Cheddar ($40 value)

0

Your Cart is Empty

17-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar

34 reviews

GLUTEN FREE | EXTREMELY KETO-FRIENDLY!

Aged for 17 years, this is as sharp as it can possibly get! As rare as it is old, and almost impossible to come by elsewhere, our 17-year-old cheddar is incredibly rich on the palette. Creamy, smooth, and impeccably sharp; this is the ultimate cheddar to spoil yourself with!  LACTOSE FREE!

• Weight: 5.5 oz
• Pairing Recommendations: Whiskey, Pilsner, Champagne, Cognac, Chardonnay


ALL NATURAL

GLUTEN-FREE

KETO-FRIENDLY

HIGH PROTEIN

LOCAL DAIRY

Why buy from Gardner's?


Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 34 Reviews
5 ★
97% 
33
4 ★
0% 
0
3 ★
3% 
1
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
0% 
0
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
    JK
    07/05/2022
    Jami K.
    United States

    Best!

    Soooo good. Shipped perfectly.

    DK
    07/01/2022
    David K.
    United States United States

    17 Year Old Cheddar

    I recently discovered aged cheddar cheese and I think that it is so good. I had no idea how cheddar cheese was supposed to taste like until my first bite! I had to have more and that's when I found Gardner's Wisconsin Cheese on the internet. The 17 year old cheddar is superb. I don't know how you can wait so long for it to age to perfection! It wakes up my taste buds. The calcium lactate crystals are such a treat. Thank you Gardners for producing such a wonder product. I really enjoy it with a glass of wine and fruit. It makes such a great gift for the holidays! David Krack

    JB
    06/15/2022
    James B.
    United States United States

    Bought for wife….?

    I purchased this cheese for my pregnant wife. -She enjoyed it, but found it to be too potent.. -As for myself, never being much of a cheese eater, I found this stuff to be INCREDIBLE. I have possible been eating fake cheese my whole life. The white crystals on the edge of this are EXPLODING with flavor. My buddy and I finished a block in 3 sittings being slightly conservative. I’ve already purchased more and a few others to try.

    AS
    05/14/2022
    Abe S.
    United States United States

    17 year cheddar

    Exactly what I would expect. Most excellent!

    FS
    05/14/2022
    Frank S.
    United States United States

    Melts in your mouth

    This is without a doubt the best aged cheddar I have ever had both in the USA and the UK.