17-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar

140 Reviews

GLUTEN FREE | EXTREMELY KETO-FRIENDLY!

Aged for 17 years, this is as sharp as it can possibly get! As rare as it is old, and almost impossible to come by elsewhere, our 17-year-old cheddar is incredibly rich on the palette. Creamy, smooth, and impeccably sharp; this is the ultimate cheddar to spoil yourself with!  LACTOSE FREE!

• Weight: 6 oz
• Pairing Recommendations: Whiskey, Pilsner, Champagne, Cognac, Chardonnay


ALL NATURAL

GLUTEN-FREE

KETO-FRIENDLY

HIGH PROTEIN

LOCAL DAIRY

Why buy from Gardner's?

Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 140 Reviews
5 ★
96% 
135
4 ★
2% 
3
3 ★
1% 
1
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
1% 
1
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
    FS
    07/22/2024
    Frank S.
    United States

    Worth every penny

    The best Cheddar I have ever had! Smooth and melts in your mouth. Great with a aged whisky.

    R
    07/20/2024
    Richard SVG verified by SHOP
    United States United States

    The sausage was delicious. Have not tried the cheese

    EH
    06/29/2024
    Eric H.
    United States United States

    17yr old cheese

    BEST cheese I’ve ever had in my life!!!!!! Get some and I promise you will want more!!!!

    O
    06/29/2024
    OldGoat
    United States United States

    My ABSOLUTE FAVORITE Cheese, although NOT for everyone

    My Wife loves your 8-years Old Super Sharp Aged Cheddar, but the 17-years Old is much too Sharp for her. Even your 13 Years Old (which is my 2nd favorite cheese) is too intense for her. Her tastes are more toward the milder Havarti, Smoked Gouda, Cheese Curds, etc. Your versions of each are SO MUCH BETTER than our local store offerings. My tastes are more toward the Sharper, Spicier, Smokier, etc. Add a little Horseradish and/or Chipotle, Anaheim, Poblano, Jalapeño (I used to like Habanero, but time has caught up with my digestive system) and I am in PURE BLISS!

    GH
    05/20/2024
    Gregery H.
    United States United States

    Love ot

    I definitely plan on buying more, my next purchase will be the cheese curds and the oldest and sharpest cheese they got